TALE OF THE TAPE

Did Mindy Kaling Make The Right Choice?

Mindy Kaling is the funny lady who has played Kelly Kapoor on The Office for the past eight seasons, but now she’s moving past Dunder Mifflin for a whole new series on Fox.  The Mindy Project will showcase Kaling’s skills in front of the camera and behind the scenes… but will the new show be worth losing the best gossip girl in Scranton?

The Office
The Mindy Project
theoffice
Ed-Weeks-Mindy-Kaling-and-Chris-Messina-of-The-Mindy-Project
MINDY'S CHARACTER
Dunder Mifflin's customer service rep wishes she was living Bridget Jones' life, and is more than a little obsessed with boys, dating and celebrity gossip.
Winner From the look of things, Mindy Lahiri, the skilled OB/GYN whose personal life is a total disaster, IS the woman Kelly wishes she was.
THE WORKPLACE
A paper company in Scranton, PA isn't the best place from which to spread your wings and fly...
Winner Mindy co-owns a medical practice, so things are looking up (as long as she can get her career off the ground!)
THE CO-WORKERS
Winner The colorful crazies at Dunder Mifflin will probably be tough to beat, even with Michael Scott out of the picture.
Mindy shares a practice with hot-headed Danny, bad news Jeremy and a bunch of potential scene-stealing supporters.
THE ROMANTIC INTERESTS
Winner Office temp turned former VP of sales Ryan Howard was absolutely toxic for Kelly, but their off-and-off-again relationship was a hilarious trainwreck.
Mindy's trying her best to keep co-worker Jeremy Reed out of her bed, but she hasn't had much luck finding any "Mr. Right"s
THE GUEST STARS
Last year saw an extended guest stint for James Spader, who kind of overstayed his welcome.
Winner The pilot alone promises turns from SNL's Bill Hader and Ed Helms (who, let's face it, is usually best in small doses).
WHO MADE IT?
Mindy Kaling not only played Kelly, but served as a chief writer for The Office for years... through the good times (Seasons 2 through 4), and the not-so-good.
Winner Mindy is one funny lady, and she's totally running the show this time out! The last time we saw a spinoff from The Office, we got Parks and Recreation, possibly the funniest sitcom on TV... maybe lightning will strike twice?
WHEN IT'S ON
Winner The Office is still the reigning king of Thursday night comedy, and NBC isn't looking to change its coveted 9pm timeslot anytime soon.
The Mindy Project will follow New Girl, another offbeat sitcom with a delightfully real-world female lead. The 9 to 10 block could be a great double dose of girl power!

The Winner Is

Ed-Weeks-Mindy-Kaling-and-Chris-Messina-of-The-Mindy-Project
Winner The Mindy Project
4 out of 7

We'll miss you, Kelly, but based on what we've seen so far, The Mindy Project looks like a real winner when it premieres this Fall! Mindy Kaling is a talented writer AND a funny actress, and we can't wait to see her finally take center stage on her own show.

MORE TALES OF THE TAPE

  1. Members of the New England Patriots celebrate with the Vince Lombardi Trophy after defeating the Seattle Seahawks 28-24 in Super Bowl XLIX. Recording artist Katy Perry performs onstage during the Pepsi Super Bowl XLIX Halftime Show.
    Was Super Bowl XLIX Or Katy Perry’s Halftime Show More Exciting?

    I don’t usually watch Super Bowl halftime shows. But when I do, it has Katy Perry. How did her performance measure up to the game?

  2. New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick talks to the media during a press conference Sunset over water
    More Shocking, Bill Belichick Not Aware Of Deflated Footballs Or Sun Setting In West?

    The sun sets in the west every day. But is that more shocking than Bill Belichick claiming ignorance in Deflate-gate?

  3. Tom Brady #12 of the New England Patriots (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images) Russell Wilson #3 of the Seattle Seahawks (Photo by Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images)
    Which Team Has The Super Bowl Edge? New England Patriots Vs. Seattle Seahawks

    The Patriots have managed to outsmart both the Ravens and Colts with trick plays in the postseason, and the Seahawks will have to be on high alert here.

See All Tales of the Tape